Building Digital Citizenship in France: Lessons from the Sens Critique project

COOPER GATEWOOD, IRIS BOYER, MARCH 2019

The advent of new communication technologies and their ubiquity has many benefits for information sharing at a global level. However, these new technologies have also created new challenges which our societies are now faced with: the spread of disinformation, manipulation and online hate.

It is essential that young people are trained to use new communication tools in a conscientious and safe way. There is growing recognition of the influence of online disinformation and conspiracy theories and the threats that these phenomena may pose to social cohesion. These dynamics have led the French government to address these issues within various relevant ministries. At the same time, many initiatives are emerging from civil society. It is in this context that the Sens Critique pilot programme arose, initiated by the think tank Civic Fab via the initiative What the Fake, and supported by a group of associations involved in various fields of expertise such as education, disinformation and counter-extremism. The programme aims to raise awareness among pupils on the dangers of fake news and hate speech. The programme includes awareness-raising exercises concerning disinformation and emotional manipulation, while at the same time building skills that may be useful for those who wish to pursue jobs in film industry professions.

The programme was piloted with 22 pupils from three schools in the Paris region. In order to evaluate the programme’s impact, pupils completed pre- and post-survey questionnaires measuring outcomes on a range of measures, including confidence in identifying trustworthy sources of information, fake news and emotional manipulation, and in creating online content of their own. Interviews were also conducted with five pupils and their parents about their feelings surrounding the programme.

The report is available in French and can be downloaded here.

DOWNLOAD REPORT

Hosting the ‘Holohoax’: A Snapshot of Holocaust Denial Across Social Media

This briefing paper examines the extent to which Holocaust denial content is readily accessible across Facebook, Twitter, Reddit and YouTube. This paper also demonstrates how appropriately applied content moderation policies can be effective in denying dangerous conspiracy theorists a public platform by examining how Holocaust denial content has decreased significantly in the past year on YouTube.

Developing a Civil Society Response to Online Manipulation

This document presents a vision for a pan-civil societal response to online manipulation. In part, it argues, this will come down to capability: building a pooled detection capacity to function as a transparent, public interest alter­native to those built by the tech giants. In part, it will require new organisational philosophies and forms of co-operation, and in part new approaches to funding and support.

The 101 of Disinformation Detection

Disinformation can threaten the activities, objectives and individuals associated with civil society groups and their work. This toolkit lays out an approach that organisations can undertake to begin to track online disinformation on subjects that they care about. The process is intended to have a very low barrier to entry, with each stage achievable using either over-the-counter or free-to-use social media analysis tools.